Skip to content
ISO 9001 · MTC Certified · ASTM / UNS Standards
Blog

Why Chromium, Nickel and Oxide Films Make Alloys Corrosion Resistant, and Why Some Alloys Still Fail

Why Chromium, Nickel and Oxide Films Make Alloys Corrosion Resistant, and Why Some Alloys Still Fail

Duralumin is stronger than pure aluminum and corrodes faster. That trade-off is the clearest illustration of how corrosion resistance actually works. Alloys like stainless steel, Hastelloy, titanium and aluminum aren’t inert. Each one survives because its surface grows a film a few nanometres thick and repairs it faster than the environment can break it down. On stainless steels and nickel-chromium alloys, chromium builds that film. Nickel mostly works underneath it: it stabilizes the crystal structure, slows pits once they start and helps in reducing acids. Aluminum and titanium make their own oxides, and copper-nickel grows a cuprous-oxide layer over months in seawater. An alloy fails when that film can’t form in the process chemistry, breaks faster than it heals, loses the water or oxygen it needs to heal, is missing from a thin band of the metal, or gets stripped off by flow. Duralumin falls into the fourth group, and so does sensitized stainless steel.

Plenty of RFQs that reach us ask for “the most corrosion-resistant alloy” and leave the process fluid blank. We understand why, because suppliers rarely explain the mechanism behind the claim. This guide works through it element by element, using the Nickel Institute, TIMET, copper industry guidance and the original 1970 study of duralumin corrosion.

Key Takeaways

  • Chromium makes steel stainless; nickel limits the damage. More than 10.5% chromium is needed for the protective film, per the Nickel Institute. Nickel (about 8% minimum for an austenitic structure) slows pit growth and improves reducing-acid resistance, but it doesn’t affect pit initiation.
  • Duralumin’s weakness comes from its strengthening copper. Al₂Cu precipitates at grain boundaries and leaves a copper-depleted band, roughly Al-0.2%Cu and a few microns wide, that pits in chloride while the grains stay passive.
  • Films differ in speed. Titanium’s oxide heals almost instantly wherever moisture or oxygen is present. Copper-nickel’s film needs 2 to 3 months in clean seawater to mature, so commissioning and flow velocity decide its life.

Chromium and the Film It Builds

Iron, chromium, aluminum and titanium all react readily with oxygen and water, so the question is never whether a metal reacts. What matters is what the reaction leaves behind. Rust on carbon steel is porous and keeps the attack going. The oxide on a chromium-bearing alloy is dense, adherent and extremely thin, and once it exists the metal underneath barely corrodes. Corrosion engineers call that state passivity. It’s different from immunity, where a metal has no tendency to react at all, a distinction we cover, along with the environments that defeat each alloy family, in Is Any Alloy Truly Corrosion-Proof?

For steel, chromium is what makes passivity possible. The Nickel Institute states that “more than 10.5% needs to be added to steel to allow the protective oxide film to form” and that “in general, the more chromium that is added, the greater the corrosion resistance.” The Australian Stainless Steel Development Association (ASSDA) uses the same 10.5% minimum and describes a film that is extremely thin, invisible and “rapidly self-repairing in the presence of oxygen.” Surface-science work reviewed by Maurice and Marcus (2018) shows this film is chromium-enriched at the nanoscale, and that how evenly the chromium is spread through it affects where it eventually breaks down.

Scratched stainless steel surface with water droplets, where the passive film re-forms in air
Scratched stainless steel surface with water droplets, where the passive film re-forms in air

The 10.5% figure on a certificate only counts if the chromium can actually reach the surface. Carbon competes for it. NASA-STD-6012A defines corrosion-resistant steel by effective chromium of at least 12%, calculated as Cr minus 11 times the carbon content, a definition we unpack in 304 vs 316 vs 18-8 vs CRES. When carbon pulls chromium out as carbides along grain boundaries, during welding or slow cooling, the metal beside each boundary can fall below what a film needs. The grains stay passive while narrow bands between them corrode. That’s sensitization, which is why low-carbon “L” grades and stabilized grades exist. Our guide to sensitization and weld decay covers prevention, and ASTM A262 testing covers verification.

Chromium oxide is at its best in oxidizing conditions such as aerated water, nitric acid and air. Chlorides are its first weakness: they break the film locally and start pits. The Nickel Institute names molybdenum and nitrogen as the elements that raise resistance to pit initiation, which is the logic behind PREN (see our article on pitting corrosion and PREN-based selection). Reducing acids are the second weakness. In hydrochloric acid, or sulfuric acid without oxidizers, a chromium oxide film is hard to form and keep, and the alloy has to lean on nickel and molybdenum.

What Nickel Adds, and What It Doesn’t

Buyers often assume nickel is the main anti-corrosion element, probably because the expensive alloys are the high-nickel ones. Its contribution is real, but it has little to do with forming the film. The Nickel Institute’s technical publication The Nickel Advantage separates out four effects.

The first is structural. About 8% nickel is the minimum needed to keep steel austenitic at room temperature, which is why Type 304 is 18% chromium and 8% nickel. Austenite is tough, ductile and weldable, and it lets alloy designers add more chromium and molybdenum without making the metal brittle.

The second is damage control. “Nickel does not influence the initiation phase but is important in reducing the rate at which both pitting and crevice corrosion propagate,” the Institute writes. A higher-nickel alloy can still pit. The pit just grows more slowly, and in a plant with annual inspections that can be the difference between finding a shallow pit and finding a leak.

The third is reducing acids. More nickel generally means better resistance to acids such as sulfuric acid. The Institute’s comparison data (from Schwind et al., 2008) gives the maximum temperature at which each grade stays below 0.13 mm/y:

Test solution304 (18Cr-8Ni)201 (low Ni, Mn-substituted)430 (no Ni)
96% sulfuric acid50 °C20 °C40 °C
85% phosphoric acid80 °C70 °C<20 °C
80% acetic acid100 °C100 °C<20 °C
50% sodium hydroxide90 °C65 °C90 °C

Source: Nickel Institute, The Nickel Advantage, Table 6.

Look at the sulfuric acid row. Grade 430, with no nickel, beat the low-nickel 201. The Institute’s own reading is that general corrosion depends on the whole combination of elements. That’s worth remembering whenever a datasheet credits one element for everything.

The fourth effect is on chloride stress corrosion cracking, and it isn’t a straight line. The Copson curve, from tests in boiling magnesium chloride, shows resistance is lowest around 8% nickel. Ferritic stainless steels with no nickel do better than standard grades with 6 to 12% nickel, and alloys above 45% nickel were found to be virtually immune in that test. Standard 304 and 316 sit near the bottom of the curve, which is why hot chloride service so often moves buyers toward duplex or nickel-base alloys (stress corrosion cracking resistant materials).

In nickel-base alloys, nickel becomes the matrix that holds large amounts of chromium, molybdenum and tungsten in solution. The corrosion literature generally credits chromium with passivity in oxidizing media and molybdenum and tungsten with resistance in reducing media. Hastelloy C-276 has both. Its typical composition on our C-276 product page is 15.5% Cr, 16.0% Mo, 3.75% W and nickel balance (about 57% by difference), comfortably past the 45% mark on the Copson curve. Hastelloy B-3 shows what happens when one side is missing. With about 28.5% molybdenum and only 1.5% chromium Haynes positions it for “pure, reducing acid service,” and it handles hydrochloric acid at all concentrations. Rolled Alloys’ datasheet spells out the catch: because B-3 “contains no significant chromium addition,” it should not be used with oxidizing salts such as ferric or cupric salts, which can form when iron or copper gets into a hydrochloric acid system. Once the chemistry turns oxidizing, there’s too little chromium to form a film. We compare it with its predecessor in Hastelloy B-2 vs B-3.

Aluminum’s Oxide and the Duralumin Paradox

Aluminum is a reactive metal that lasts for decades in ordinary air, for the same basic reason as stainless steel: a dense oxide film forms on any fresh surface almost immediately. The difference lies in the film’s chemistry. Aluminum oxide is stable only within a pH window of roughly 4 to 8.5, according to the SUEZ Water Handbook, and it dissolves outside that window. The same handbook notes that around 20 ppb of dissolved copper ions can trigger galvanic attack on aluminum, an early hint about copper.

Duralumin was developed by the German metallurgist Alfred Wilm, who found that aluminum with about 4% copper hardened when left at room temperature after quenching. It reached the market in 1909. Its modern descendant, alloy 2024, contains 3.8 to 4.9% copper, 1.2 to 1.8% magnesium and 0.3 to 0.9% manganese, and Hydro’s comparison of aluminum alloy groups rates the copper-bearing 2xxx series poor for corrosion resistance and normally in need of protection.

Galvele and De Micheli explained why in a 1970 Corrosion Science paper on aged Al-4%Cu. During age hardening, copper-rich θ-phase (Al₂Cu) precipitates faster at grain boundaries than inside the grains, and pulls copper out of the metal around it. The band next to each boundary ends up close to Al-0.2%Cu. That depleted band acts as the anode, while the grain bodies and the Al₂Cu particles act as cathodes, and earlier researchers had measured differences of around 100 mV between boundaries and grains. What Galvele and De Micheli added was the role of chloride. The depleted zone has a lower pitting potential than the grains, so there is a range, about 100 mV wide in their tests, where the boundary zone pits while the grains stay passive. Corrosion then concentrates in a layer only a few microns thick. Whether an alloy is susceptible, they found, depends on its heat-treatment conditions.

So the copper that strengthens duralumin is also what weakens it. The usual industrial fix is alclad sheet, which bonds a high-purity aluminum or Al-1Zn surface layer to the 2024 core. The cladding is more anodic than the core and corrodes in its place.

For anyone buying CRA alloys, duralumin is worth understanding because sensitized stainless steel fails the same way. In both cases the average chemistry looks fine on a certificate, and a thin band along the grain boundaries ends up chemically different from the grains, so corrosion concentrates there. In both cases the trigger is thermal history, and the grade name on the order says nothing about it. That’s why we ask about heat treatment, welding procedures and intergranular corrosion results, not only composition, when an alloy is headed for aggressive service.

Copper-Nickel and Titanium: Two Very Different Films

Copper-nickel builds its film in seawater

Copper-nickel has no chromium, so it can’t rely on a passive oxide that appears the moment the surface is cut. Its protection is a corrosion-product film that builds up in seawater. Copper industry guidance describes the film as predominantly cuprous oxide, often containing nickel and iron oxides, cuprous hydroxychloride and cupric oxide. An initial film forms over the first couple of days, but it takes 2 to 3 months to fully mature. In one condenser study cited in that guidance, copper in the outlet water had fallen to about the intake level after three months.

inline 02
Seawater and process piping in a ship’s engine room

The two standard grades are 90/10 (UNS C70600, about 9 to 11% nickel) and 70/30 (UNS C71500, about 29 to 33% nickel). Both carry 1.0 to 1.8% iron and up to 1.0% manganese under ASTM B466, as we explain in What Is a Copper-Nickel Alloy?, and the iron is there to toughen the film against erosion-corrosion. Our C70600 product page lists a typical 10.0% Ni, 1.5% Fe and 1.0% Mn.

A film that has to grow brings two weak points. Flow is the first: above a certain velocity, shear strips the film faster than it re-forms. British Standard BS MA18, as summarized in copper industry guidance, sets maximum design velocities of 3.5 m/s for 90/10 and 4 m/s for 70/30 in pipes of 100 mm and larger, with lower limits for smaller pipes. Condensers and heat exchangers have run successfully at up to 2.5 m/s for 90/10 and 3 m/s for 70/30. The extra nickel in 70/30 is what buys the margin, and our C70600 vs C71500 comparison shows how to choose. The second weak point is the first few weeks. The guidance stresses that initial exposure to clean seawater is crucial. A new line commissioned with sulfide-polluted water, or left stagnant in harbor water before the film matures, can start with a weaker film. Strictly speaking that is a commissioning problem, though the alloy usually gets the blame.

Titanium heals almost instantly

Titanium’s reputation comes almost entirely from its oxide. TIMET’s corrosion manual gives unusually detailed numbers. A clean titanium surface exposed to air forms a film 12 to 16 ångströms thick immediately, about 50 ångströms after 70 days, 80 to 90 ångströms after 545 days and around 250 ångströms after four years. The film runs from TiO₂ at the surface through Ti₂O₃ to TiO at the metal.

The healing is what sets it apart. TIMET says titanium “is capable of healing this film almost instantly in any environment where a trace of moisture or oxygen is present because of its strong affinity for oxygen.” That’s why it tolerates seawater and chlorides that pit many stainless steels. TIMET also reports no recorded case of microbiologically influenced corrosion on titanium, and notes that titanium isn’t subject to galvanic corrosion in seawater, though it can speed up corrosion of a less noble metal joined to it (see galvanic corrosion prevention).

Its limits follow from the same mechanism. The film “is only attacked by a few substances, most notably, hydrofluoric acid,” and TIMET warns against anhydrous conditions with no oxygen source, since a damaged film may not regenerate. Crevices are the other limit: unalloyed titanium can suffer localized pitting or crevice corrosion in seawater above 82 °C. Small alloy additions fix this. TIMET’s Code 12 (0.3% Mo, 0.8% Ni) and 50A .15Pd (Grade 2 plus 0.15% Pd) resist crevice corrosion in seawater up to 260 °C. For the two standard grades, see titanium Grade 2 vs Grade 5. In hot reducing acids, we would normally steer a buyer toward a nickel-molybdenum alloy rather than titanium.

Five Ways the Film Loses, and What to Ask Before You Order

Most CRA failures we look into fall into five groups, and none of them points to a “bad” alloy. B-3, titanium and 90/10 copper-nickel all show up below, and all three are excellent inside their limits.

Sometimes the film simply can’t form in the process chemistry: aluminum outside pH 4 to 8.5, or B-3 meeting ferric or cupric ions. The protection here is a complete fluid analysis, including oxidizers and pH excursions, not just the main acid. In other cases the film breaks locally faster than it heals, as with stainless steel pitting in chlorides or unalloyed titanium crevices above 82 °C, and the question becomes whether the PREN or the alloy grade matches the chloride level, the temperature and the crevice geometry. A third group is quieter. The healing supply runs out when titanium goes anhydrous or a stagnant crevice starves of oxygen, so it’s worth asking whether the service can go dry, deaerated or stagnant during upsets and shutdowns. The fourth is the grain-boundary problem shared by sensitized stainless steel and duralumin, and the evidence that rules it out is the heat-treatment condition on the mill certificate, the welding procedure, the carbon content and an ASTM A262 or equivalent result. The fifth is mechanical: flow strips a grown film, as with 90/10 copper-nickel above 3.5 m/s in pipe of 100 mm or more, so the number that matters is the velocity at the most turbulent point, not the average.

Whatever the group, the delivered material has to be the alloy the mechanism depends on. An EN 10204 3.1 certificate with full heat traceability, plus positive material identification on arrival, confirms that.

If there’s one habit worth taking from all this, it’s asking which film is doing the work. On a 316L heat exchanger it’s chromium oxide, helped by molybdenum. On a 90/10 seawater line it’s a cuprous-oxide layer that needs clean water and a few months. On a titanium condenser it’s TiO₂, which heals as long as some water or oxygen is around. The risks then become fairly predictable: a pH excursion, an oxidizing contaminant, a weld that sat too long in the sensitizing range, a pump discharge running faster than design.

We supply nickel-base alloys, titanium, super austenitic stainless steel and copper-nickel with EN 10204 3.1 mill test certificates. Send us the process fluid, temperature range, contaminants and flow conditions, and our team will tell you which film your application relies on and which grades are worth shortlisting. Contact us here.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is nickel what makes stainless steel “stainless”?

No, chromium does. Nickel keeps the structure austenitic, slows the growth of pits and crevices that have already started, and helps in reducing acids such as sulfuric acid. According to the Nickel Institute it has no influence on whether a pit starts in the first place.

Why is 2024 aluminum often supplied as alclad?

Because the bare alloy’s 3.8 to 4.9% copper leaves it prone to intergranular and pitting attack. A high-purity aluminum or Al-1Zn layer bonded to the surface is more anodic than the core, so the cladding corrodes first and the core stays protected.

Hastelloy or titanium: which resists corrosion better?

That depends on the chemistry. Titanium usually wins in seawater, chlorides and oxidizing media. Nickel-molybdenum alloys such as Hastelloy B-3 or C-276 normally outperform it in hot reducing acids like hydrochloric acid. Titanium should also be kept away from hydrofluoric acid and from anhydrous service where its film can’t regenerate.

References

  1. Nickel Institute, The Nickel Advantage: Nickel in Stainless Steel, December 2008 (chapters 1–2, Table 6, Figure 10). https://www.centroinox.it/sites/default/files/monografia_pdf/nickel_in_stainless_steel.pdf
  2. Australian Stainless Steel Development Association (ASSDA), “What is stainless steel?” https://assda.asn.au/stainless-steel/what-is-stainless-steel
  3. V. Maurice and P. Marcus, “Current developments of nanoscale insight into corrosion protection by passive oxide films,” Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science, 2018. https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.10689
  4. NASA-STD-6012A, effective chromium definition for corrosion-resistant steel (as discussed in our 304 vs 316 vs 18-8 vs CRES article).
  5. Haynes International, HASTELLOY® B-3® alloy brochure. https://haynesintl.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/pdf-alloy-b-3.pdf
  6. SUEZ Water Handbook, “Aluminium.” https://www.suezwaterhandbook.com/Water-and-generalities/Corrosion-in-metal-and-concrete/Corrosion-in-metallic-materials/aluminium
  7. Hydro, “Here are the differences in corrosion behavior between the aluminium alloy groups.” https://www.shapesbyhydro.com/en/knowledge/here-are-the-differences-in-corrosion-behavior-between-the-aluminium-alloy-groups/
  8. J. R. Galvele and S. M. de De Micheli, “Mechanism of intergranular corrosion of Al-Cu alloys,” Corrosion Science 10 (1970) 795. https://nuclea.cnea.gob.ar/bitstreams/d394403a-57ad-4ff3-b5ba-cfa6edb0ce20/download
  9. “2024 aluminium alloy” and “Duralumin,” Wikipedia (composition per ASM Aerospace Specification Metals). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_aluminium_alloy
  10. Copper Development Association, copper-nickel seawater guidance, including “Guidelines for the Use of Copper Alloys in Seawater” (film formation, BS MA18 velocity limits). https://www.copper.org/applications/marine/cuni/
  11. TIMET, Corrosion Resistance of Titanium. https://www.timet.com/assets/local/documents/technicalmanuals/corrosion.pdf
  12. Rolled Alloys, HASTELLOY® B-3® datasheet. https://www.rolledalloys.ca/wp-content/uploads/HASTELLOY-B-3_Datasheet-rolled-alloys.pdf
← Back to Blog Get a Quote →
From the Blog

Latest Articles

All Articles →
1